Call Discuss your project
Practical Knowledge
Articles and guides on
Value Analysis and Value Management
Here you will find background information, methodological knowledge and practical ideas
for cost optimisation, Function Analysis and value-oriented
product development.

A figure looks exact – a cost model is not automatically so

Technical content by Dr.-Ing. Jörg Marchthaler, Value Coaching Marchthaler

Cost engineering models can output results down to individual euros or cents.

This precision of presentation must not be confused with actual certainty.

A cost model is based on input variables and assumptions.

Examples:

  • material price
  • material utilisation
  • cycle time
  • machine hourly rate
  • labour costs
  • scrap
  • tool life
  • production volume

If these values change, the result changes too.

Document data sources

For important input variables, it should be clear:

  • which source they come from
  • which point in time they relate to
  • whether they are real actual values or assumptions
  • which region or quantity they apply to

This keeps the model verifiable.

Make assumptions visible

Uncertainty is not automatically a problem.

The real problem is invisible uncertainty.

If a cycle time has been estimated, for example, this should be indicated.

The team can then check specifically later whether this assumption is relevant to the decision.

Consider sensitivity

Not every input variable influences the result to the same extent.

A sensitivity analysis can help to find out:

Which assumptions change the result most significantly?

Data collection should concentrate on these variables.

Ranges instead of spurious precision

In early development phases, exact information is often not available.

A range can then be more meaningful than a seemingly precise single value.

For example, a solution can initially be classified as:

  • low cost range
  • expected range
  • upper cost range

and discussed on that basis.

The specific form of presentation should match the company's decision-making process.

Using cost models for decisions

The aim of a model is not to be as complicated as possible.

It is meant to support decisions.

Examples:

  • compare technical concepts
  • check the plausibility of supplier quotations
  • make cost drivers visible
  • check target costs
  • prepare the Business Case

Link to Value Analysis

Value Analysis requires sufficiently reliable economic information.

At the same time, a project should not wait for perfect data if robust lines of enquiry are already apparent.

The art lies in achieving the accuracy required for the particular decision.

Further reading

We Use Cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us improve this website and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether to allow cookies. Please note that if you decline, some features of the site may no longer be available.