A competitor product does not only show which functions are offered.
It also shows:
- technical architecture
- number of components
- use of materials
- manufacturing process
- degree of integration
- standardisation
- design priorities
A systematic teardown can make this information visible.
What does teardown mean?
In an industrial context, teardown refers to the structured disassembly or detailed examination of a product.
Depending on the objective, the following can be documented:
- components
- materials
- mass
- joining techniques
- manufacturing process
- indications of suppliers
- technical characteristics
- estimated cost structures
The examination must respect the legal framework and intellectual property rights.
Don’t stop at comparing parts
A teardown is particularly valuable when it does not merely compare component with component.
The further-reaching question is:
How does the competitor perform the same function?
This can reveal that a competitor product:
- integrates functions
- needs fewer components
- uses a different architecture
- prioritises different requirements
- uses a different manufacturing process
Cost models complement the benchmark
Depending on data quality and expertise, cost models can be built from technical data.
These are particularly useful for understanding:
- which solution appears economically simpler
- where material or process advantages lie
- which cost drivers can be assumed
However, estimated benchmark costs are not the competitor’s actual costs as publicly known.
Taking customer performance into account
A competitor may be cheaper because it offers less performance.
The comparison should therefore always also take into account:
- Functions
- Customer requirements
- Quality
- performance level
- target group
Only then does a meaningful value comparison emerge.
Teardown as input for creativity
The benchmark does not provide a ready-made solution.
It can, however, generate opportunity areas:
- function integration
- alternative materials
- different manufacturing processes
- simplification
- standardisation
- different interfaces
Teardown is thus one possible input into Value Analysis.
