Call Discuss your project
Value Analysis and Value Management
Methods for greater transparency
in functions, costs and
customer value
This page brings together the key fundamentals, analytical approaches
and tools for structured Value Analysis and Value Management projects.

Competitor products contain technical and economic information

Technical content by Dr.-Ing. Jörg Marchthaler, Value Coaching Marchthaler

A competitor product does not only show which functions are offered.

It also shows:

  • technical architecture
  • number of components
  • use of materials
  • manufacturing process
  • degree of integration
  • standardisation
  • design priorities

A systematic teardown can make this information visible.

What does teardown mean?

In an industrial context, teardown refers to the structured disassembly or detailed examination of a product.

Depending on the objective, the following can be documented:

  • components
  • materials
  • mass
  • joining techniques
  • manufacturing process
  • indications of suppliers
  • technical characteristics
  • estimated cost structures

The examination must respect the legal framework and intellectual property rights.

Don’t stop at comparing parts

A teardown is particularly valuable when it does not merely compare component with component.

The further-reaching question is:

How does the competitor perform the same function?

This can reveal that a competitor product:

  • integrates functions
  • needs fewer components
  • uses a different architecture
  • prioritises different requirements
  • uses a different manufacturing process

Cost models complement the benchmark

Depending on data quality and expertise, cost models can be built from technical data.

These are particularly useful for understanding:

  • which solution appears economically simpler
  • where material or process advantages lie
  • which cost drivers can be assumed

However, estimated benchmark costs are not the competitor’s actual costs as publicly known.

Taking customer performance into account

A competitor may be cheaper because it offers less performance.

The comparison should therefore always also take into account:

  • Functions
  • Customer requirements
  • Quality
  • performance level
  • target group

Only then does a meaningful value comparison emerge.

Teardown as input for creativity

The benchmark does not provide a ready-made solution.

It can, however, generate opportunity areas:

  • function integration
  • alternative materials
  • different manufacturing processes
  • simplification
  • standardisation
  • different interfaces

Teardown is thus one possible input into Value Analysis.

Further reading

We Use Cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us improve this website and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether to allow cookies. Please note that if you decline, some features of the site may no longer be available.