Companies often have numerous products, variants or assemblies under cost pressure. At the same time, time, specialist resources and management attention are limited.
The central question is therefore not only:
“Where could we reduce costs?”
but first:
“For which product or project is a structured use of our resources most worthwhile?”
A Project Potential Assessment helps to compare and prioritise possible Value Analysis and cost optimisation projects systematically.
Why project selection matters before the project starts
Even a methodologically well-run Value Analysis project can be the wrong investment if the product under examination has little commercial relevance, can hardly be changed or important data is missing.
Conversely, attractive projects are often left untouched because their potential is not presented in a comparable way.
A structured potential assessment therefore creates a basis for decisions before larger project resources are committed.
Which criteria can be considered?
The specific evaluation depends on the company and its strategy. Possible criteria include:
- current manufacturing cost volume
- expected future unit volumes
- product life and life cycle
- gap to cost targets
- competitive pressure
- potential for technical change
- degree of variant diversity and complexity
- effort required for changes
- available development resources
- strategic importance
- relevance to customers
- implementation timeframe
The key is not to use as many criteria as possible. They must fit the specific decision situation.
From gut feeling to comparable decisions
Without a structured evaluation, individual opinions often dominate:
- Sales considers product A particularly important.
- Procurement sees major price levers for product B.
- R&D expects technical opportunities for product C.
- Management prioritises product D because of high unit volumes.
All of these perspectives may be justified. The potential assessment brings them into a common evaluation logic.
This makes it transparent why one project is prioritised and another is put on hold for the time being.
A Project Potential Assessment is more than a ranking
A simple ranking is not enough to start a project.
For prioritised candidates, the following should then be clarified:
- What exactly is the study scope?
- Which cost targets can realistically be investigated?
- What data is needed?
- Which departments need to take part?
- What technical boundary conditions exist?
- Which decisions can be made within the project?
- Which dates and milestones are required?
This turns an attractive candidate into a clearly defined project charter.
Link to Value Analysis
The Project Potential Assessment comes before the actual Value Analysis project.
It determines where the subsequent intensive work on customer requirements, functions, function costs, solution development and evaluation is particularly worthwhile.
Especially when there are several possible products or cost topics, this upstream selection prevents project teams from being deployed on a “whoever shouts loudest” basis.
Typical process
A possible process includes:
- identifying project candidates
- defining decision criteria
- compiling available data
- evaluating candidates on a comparable basis
- documenting uncertainties and dependencies
- prioritising projects
- defining the objective, scope, team and data requirements for the selected projects
The methodology should be as simple as possible and as detailed as necessary.
When is a Project Potential Assessment particularly useful?
- before a major cost initiative
- when there are several product families or variants
- before budget and resource decisions
- when cost reduction projects are launched regularly
- when management, R&D and procurement have different priorities
- when a suitable pilot or flagship project is needed first
Project Potential Assessment with Value Coaching
Value Coaching uses the Project Potential Assessment as an upstream step when it is not already clear which project should be tackled.
The aim is a clearly defined project charter with objectives, study scope, team structure, the required data basis and an agreed project plan.
The assessment does not replace the subsequent Value Analysis project. It lays the foundation for starting the right project with the right prerequisites.
What this looks like in practice is shown by the Dornbracht project example: Project Potential Assessment before the first Value Analysis project. There, the products were first screened for their suitability for an initial Value Analysis project. A design-oriented overhead shower was selected.
Further reading
- Systematic product cost reduction
- Cost reduction project and cost reduction workshop
- Business Case for cost reduction measures
- Our consulting process for Value Analysis projects
- What are Value Analysis / Value Engineering and Value Management?
- Value Analysis project examples and references
- Discuss your project: book an initial consultation


