Call Discuss your project
Practical Knowledge
Articles and guides on
Value Analysis and Value Management
Here you will find background information, methodological knowledge and practical ideas
for cost optimisation, Function Analysis and value-oriented
product development.

A technical requirement can be correct – and still unnecessarily expensive

Technical content by Dr.-Ing. Jörg Marchthaler, Value Coaching Marchthaler

Tolerances, surfaces, material requirements or performance reserves often have a considerable influence on manufacturing costs.

It becomes problematic when requirements are carried over for years without regularly checking which function they still safeguard today.

The key question is therefore not:

“How can we reduce the specification?”

But rather:

“Which requirement is necessary for the function to be performed reliably?”

Why tight tolerances can drive costs

The tighter a permissible deviation becomes, the more – depending on the process – the requirements for:

  • production,
  • machine capability,
  • measuring equipment,
  • inspection,
  • scrap,
  • rework,
  • process stability

can increase.

This does not mean that tight tolerances are wrong in principle.

They must be used where they are functionally necessary.

Requirements that have grown over time

Specifications often arise from:

  • earlier problems,
  • safety margins,
  • existing manufacturing processes,
  • customer specifications,
  • standards,
  • the experience of individual engineers.

Over time, it can become unclear why a value was originally specified.

Value Analysis can help to restore the link to the function.

Functions as the benchmark

Instead of questioning the drawing in isolation, the following is examined:

  • Which function depends on the specification?
  • Which minimum requirement is needed to perform the function?
  • what interactions exist with other functions?
  • what risks arise from a change?
  • what tests or trials would be necessary?

This makes the discussion technically more robust.

Separating customer requirements from internal requirements

Not every internal specification is directly a customer requirement.

A customer may require, for example:

  • a service life,
  • a noise limit,
  • a level of precision,
  • a level of reliability.

How these requirements are implemented technically is often the task of the development department.

This can make alternative technical solutions possible without reducing customer value.

Considering tolerance chains and the overall system

Individual tolerances can influence one another within the system.

Optimisation should therefore not take place only locally.

Through a change to one component,

  • assembly,
  • function,
  • tightness,
  • service life,
  • noise,
  • safety

can be affected.

Value Analysis provides the framework, but detailed technical analyses must be carried out by the relevant specialist disciplines.

Typical lines of enquiry

Depending on the product, the following can be investigated:

  • widening tolerances
  • alternative datum and measurement concepts
  • self-centring design
  • function integration
  • a different manufacturing process
  • standard parts
  • modified surface requirements
  • alternative materials
  • a more robust architecture

Further reading

We Use Cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us improve this website and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether to allow cookies. Please note that if you decline, some features of the site may no longer be available.