Call Discuss your project
Practical Knowledge
Articles and guides on
Value Analysis and Value Management
Here you will find background information, methodological knowledge and practical ideas
for cost optimisation, Function Analysis and value-oriented
product development.

Reducing material costs – without stopping at the bill of materials

Technical content by Dr.-Ing. Jörg Marchthaler, Value Coaching Marchthaler

In technical products, materials and manufacturing are often among the most visible cost blocks.

It is therefore an obvious step to look for:

  • cheaper materials,
  • other suppliers,
  • alternative manufacturing processes,
  • fewer machining steps.

These are the obvious starting points.

These approaches can make sense.

Value Analysis, however, broadens the question:

Why is this material or process needed at all – which function and which requirement lie behind it?

Material is a solution, not a function

A particular material is used because it provides certain properties.

For example:

  • strength,
  • stiffness,
  • corrosion resistance,
  • thermal conductivity,
  • electrical insulation,
  • appearance,
  • weight.

Once these requirements are clear, alternative materials or other technical solutions can be examined.

Manufacturing processes influence the design

Design and manufacturing must not be optimised separately from one another.

A component can be complex to produce with one process but well suited to another.

Possible lines of enquiry include, for example:

  • casting instead of machining,
  • a profile instead of an individual part,
  • forming instead of a joined structure,
  • standard semi-finished products instead of a special shape,
  • plastic instead of metal – or vice versa,
  • additive manufacturing for suitable applications,
  • assembly integration.

Which alternative makes sense depends on volumes, geometry, requirements, investment and other constraints.

Overall cost-effectiveness instead of unit price

A supposedly cheaper material can generate additional costs.

Depending on the project, the following need to be considered:

  • material price,
  • machinability,
  • tooling costs,
  • scrap,
  • cycle time,
  • assembly,
  • surface,
  • logistics,
  • quality,
  • service life,
  • recycling or environmental impact.

A unit price alone should therefore not be the only comparison.

Function Analysis opens up alternatives

Once the task of a component is described in functional terms, the solution space can widen.

For example, instead of the question:

“Which cheaper material is suitable for this component?”

the question can be asked:

“How can we perform the function with less overall effort?”

Changes to geometry, function integration, standard parts or a different working principle can then also be considered.

Using supplier know-how

Suppliers often know manufacturing technologies that are not fully transparent internally.

With special processes in particular, early supplier involvement can help to align design constraints more closely with cost-effective manufacturing options.

Further reading

We Use Cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us improve this website and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether to allow cookies. Please note that if you decline, some features of the site may no longer be available.