In technical products, materials and manufacturing are often among the most visible cost blocks.
It is therefore an obvious step to look for:
- cheaper materials,
- other suppliers,
- alternative manufacturing processes,
- fewer machining steps.
These are the obvious starting points.
These approaches can make sense.
Value Analysis, however, broadens the question:
Why is this material or process needed at all – which function and which requirement lie behind it?
Material is a solution, not a function
A particular material is used because it provides certain properties.
For example:
- strength,
- stiffness,
- corrosion resistance,
- thermal conductivity,
- electrical insulation,
- appearance,
- weight.
Once these requirements are clear, alternative materials or other technical solutions can be examined.
Manufacturing processes influence the design
Design and manufacturing must not be optimised separately from one another.
A component can be complex to produce with one process but well suited to another.
Possible lines of enquiry include, for example:
- casting instead of machining,
- a profile instead of an individual part,
- forming instead of a joined structure,
- standard semi-finished products instead of a special shape,
- plastic instead of metal – or vice versa,
- additive manufacturing for suitable applications,
- assembly integration.
Which alternative makes sense depends on volumes, geometry, requirements, investment and other constraints.
Overall cost-effectiveness instead of unit price
A supposedly cheaper material can generate additional costs.
Depending on the project, the following need to be considered:
- material price,
- machinability,
- tooling costs,
- scrap,
- cycle time,
- assembly,
- surface,
- logistics,
- quality,
- service life,
- recycling or environmental impact.
A unit price alone should therefore not be the only comparison.
Function Analysis opens up alternatives
Once the task of a component is described in functional terms, the solution space can widen.
For example, instead of the question:
“Which cheaper material is suitable for this component?”
the question can be asked:
“How can we perform the function with less overall effort?”
Changes to geometry, function integration, standard parts or a different working principle can then also be considered.
Using supplier know-how
Suppliers often know manufacturing technologies that are not fully transparent internally.
With special processes in particular, early supplier involvement can help to align design constraints more closely with cost-effective manufacturing options.
Further reading
- Systematic product cost reduction
- Involving suppliers in Value Analysis projects
- Function Analysis: looking at tasks instead of components
- Function Cost Analysis: allocating costs to functions
- Benchmarking in Value Analysis
- Tolerances and specifications as cost drivers
- Sustainability and Value Engineering
