Call Discuss your project
Practical Knowledge
Articles and guides on
Value Analysis and Value Management
Here you will find background information, methodological knowledge and practical ideas
for cost optimisation, Function Analysis and value-oriented
product development.

Value Analysis is best learned on a real task

Technical content by Dr.-Ing. Jörg Marchthaler, Value Coaching Marchthaler

Companies that want to introduce Value Analysis or Value Engineering for the first time often face two questions:

How do we train our employees?

and:

Which project do we start with?

Ideally, both should be considered together.

A suitable pilot project makes it possible to apply the methodology to a real business task while building internal knowledge at the same time.

Why a pilot project makes sense

Pure method training teaches the fundamentals.

The real challenges, however, arise in application:

  • defining functions precisely,
  • bringing different departments together,
  • allocating costs reliably,
  • weighting customer requirements,
  • facilitating creativity phases,
  • evaluating ideas,
  • managing implementation.

A pilot project makes these questions tangible.

Choosing the right pilot project

The first project should be relevant enough for its results to be visible to the company.

At the same time, it must not be so politically or technically overloaded that the new methodology gets lost in the project risk.

Suitable criteria may include:

  • noticeable economic pressure to act,
  • sufficiently reliable data,
  • genuine improvement potential,
  • a manageable system boundary,
  • an available cross-functional team,
  • management support,
  • realistic implementation options.

A Project Potential Assessment can support the selection.

Combining external facilitation with internal involvement

When introducing the method for the first time, external facilitation can help to keep the methodological process on a steady course.

At the same time, internal employees should work actively on the project and take on responsibility step by step.

This produces not only a project result, but also competence.

Linking project and qualification

A sensible introduction path might consist, for example, of:

  1. fundamentals training
  2. selection of a pilot project
  3. a supported Value Analysis project
  4. reflection and transfer
  5. in-depth qualification of internal employees
  6. further projects with growing internal responsibility

The specific design depends on the company and on its existing methodological knowledge.

After the pilot project

What matters is what happens after the first project.

Questions to clarify include, for example:

  • Which employees should facilitate further projects?
  • How are project topics selected?
  • which standards and templates are used?
  • how are project experiences documented?
  • who tracks implementation?
  • what qualification is required?

On a larger scale, this can give rise to an organisational structure such as a Value Management Office.

Two documented examples: in the Carl Zeiss Meditec project example: pilot project with introduction strategy, a strategy for embedding the method in the development process was created alongside the project result. In the thyssenkrupp project example: pilot projects to introduce Value Analysis, the method was trialled in several pilot projects.

Further reading

We Use Cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us improve this website and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether to allow cookies. Please note that if you decline, some features of the site may no longer be available.